Journal Refuses To Retract Controversial Paxil Study

The Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry says they refuse to retract a study known as Study 329, even though following a lawsuit with GlaxoSmithKline the controversial study involving Paxil was proven to be misleading and distorted.

One global nonprofit Healthy Skepticism expressed concern that the study, which identified the drug Paxil as an effective combatant of depression in children, “seriously misrepresented both the effectiveness and the safety” of the drug. They say that the study’s continued citation was harmful to children, since some children committed suicide after being prescribed Paxil.

Last summer, GlaxoSmithKline agreed to plead guilty and pay $3 billion to resolve criminal and civil charges in connection with off-label promotion of several drugs, failing to report safety data and reporting false prices. One infraction, in particular, concerned this controversial study, further leading some to believe that it is without question that the study be retracted.

The feds claimed the GSK participated in preparing, publishing and distributing what was called a “misleading medical journal article” because the results misreported that a Paxil clinical trial demonstrated efficacy in treating depression in patients under age 18, when the study failed to demonstrate efficacy.

Prosecutors accused GSK sales representatives of then using the article to promote the use of the drug for depressed youth. Sales reps invited prescribing psychiatrists to luxury resorts for “Paxil forum meetings” where they were treated to fancy dinners and free entertainment like sailing trips and balloon rides.

Reports of teens committing suicide while taking Paxil began surfacing in 2003, and the FDA discovered that 10 of the 93 Paxil patients in Study 329 had attempted suicide or thought about it, versus one out of the 87 patients on placebo. In 2004, the FDA added a black-box warning on the drug’s label about the increased risk of suicidal thoughts in teens who take it.

After the settlement with GSK, however, several detractors hoped this presented a fresh opportunity to convince the journal to issue a retraction. Unfortunately, as of yet this has not been the case.  The journal has again declined to do so, according to an e-mail exchange with an academic who has previously pushed for retraction.

In a Dec. 21, 2012, e-mail, AACAP editor-in-chief and Yale University psychiatry professor Andres Martin wrote that the “journal’s editorial team undertook a thorough evaluation of the article, the legal settlement and related materials. The authors of the article were contacted and asked to respond to the questions and concerns raised by the settlement.

“After a comprehensive and extensive review, the journal editors found no basis for retraction or other editorial action,” he wrote about what he called a “lengthy” review. His e-mail was addressed to Jon Jureidini, a psychiatry professor at the University of Adelaide in Australia.

Martin was responding to a letter that Jureidini wrote last summer, seeking a retraction. “Given the clear misrepresentations present in the article, it would be appropriate for the journal to withdraw it immediately. Decisive action would benefit the psychiatric and general community, given that this paper inappropriately exaggerates the efficacy of paroxetine in young patients. It would also be beneficial to the journal’s reputation,” Jureidini wrote.

Brown University has joined the journal refusing to retract the study.

You May Also Like


GET HELP NOW!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.



, ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

GET HELP NOW!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Latest Drug Injury News

Merck’s Falsification of Vaccine Data Exposed

Merk’s dirty little secret has been exposed. A pair of lawsuits, one filed by former employees of Merck and the other by doctors, alleged the company knew its mumps vaccine was less effective than the supposed 95 percent efficiency level. According to court documents the former virologists employed by Merck filed a whistleblower lawsuit four […]

Testosterone Therapy Linked To Heart-Attack, Stroke and Death

Millions of men have turned to testosterone therapy to treat symptoms of aging. However, they may not be aware that they are putting themselves at risk for heart attack or stroke. According to the latest study published in the journal PLOS ONE, researchers report that within 90 days of taking the hormone the risk of […]

What Is Doribax?

According to the FDA the antibacterial drug Doribax, that has been used to treat patients who develop pneumonia on ventilators, carries an increased risk of death and has a lower clinical cure rate by injection compared a similar drug known as Primaxin. What is Doribax? Doribax is an antibiotic that fights serious infections caused by […]

Is Using Tylenol or Ibuprofen During Pregnancy linked to ADHD?

What is a mother to do if she becomes ill during pregnancy?  The risks of consuming common drugs when pregnant are complex.  Although many doctors assure mothers that taking Tylenol is safe, a recent study by JAMA Pediatrics suggests otherwise.  The study found that mothers who used Tylenol for fever reduction while pregnant reported greater […]

Paxil Linked To Breast Cancer

City of Hope Cancer researchers indicate that a new test called the AroER Tri-Screen, desgined to look for drug side effects that could cause cancer, found a potential link between Paxil and breast cancer.  Paxil is a widely prescribed anti depressant. Research Researchers have found that Paxil has a weak estrogen effect that could increase […]

Latest Medical Device Injury News

Report Raises Concerns Over Heart Defibrillator Leads

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has just announced that they received a report that a St. Jude Durata cardiac defibrillator lead conductor became externalized; meaning the wire carrying electricity from the heart defibrillator to the heart was exposed through its insulation, a potentially dangerous and life-threatening defect.

HeartSine Class 1 Defibrillator Recall

HeartSine sent out a letter to customers in September, warning that the defibrillators may intermittently turn on and off, eventually depleting the battery.

FDA Medical Device Approval Based On Little Evidence

More than half of the high-risk cardiovascular devices approved in the past decade had no supporting active control data.

St. Jude Medical Gets FDA Warning

St. Jude Medical Inc. said it received a FDA warning about manufacturing and quality-control problems at its Sylmar, California, plant.

Hospira Still Facing Manufacturing And Regulatory Issues

Hospira has sent out 11 device notifications so far in 2013, including recall and device corrections. The company also said it sent notices to customers about some of its infusion pumps that had to either be recalled, fixed or adjusted.